While there’s plenty of debate about the level of talent of certain divas ― Rihanna, Britney Spears, and Nicki Minaj amongst them ― one starlet is almost never criticized for bringing her A-game. That’s Alicia Keys, whose soulful stylings are on display in her new LP Girl On Fire (out today).

Maybe Alicia’s earnest piano-driven tunes aren’t everyone’s cup of tea, but the “Empire State of Mind” signer proved she was game to poke fun at her ballad-heavy catalog when she appeared on Jimmy Fallon, letting loose a heartfelt rendition of… well, the last song you’d ever expect to find Alicia Keys pouring her heart out about.

 

Related Article: Alicia Keys, Kanye West & More Join Hurricane Sandy Benefit Concert!

The song, of course, is the theme to the 80’s/90’s Disney cartoon Adventures of the Gummi Bears. Not exactly a Grammy-winner, but it sure did make us giggle as performed so straight-facedly by Alicia Keys.

Did Alicia have you fooled for a second there? Let us know what you thought!