Here at Hollywire, we’ve been big fans for former X-Factor contestant Carly Rose Sonenclar since we first saw her on the talent competition show. But when she takes on a song by One Direction and puts her own unique twist on it, well we just can’t help but love her even more! But here’s a question for you: which version of the song do you prefer?

Chelsea Briggs shows you both in today’s Hollywire Hot Minute!

Related Article: Fifth Harmony Takes On One Direction & More of Their Best Covers!

Both versions of the song are way different – 1D with their high-energy club beat and Carly slowing it down for the ultimate love ballad – which makes them sound like different songs, right?

Carly has been receiving tons of praise for her cover, even getting a tweet from Niall Horan himself! He tweeted, “you are an incredible talent..and thank you for doing the cover.” Um, is that the ultimate compliment or what?

Which version of the song do you prefer? 1D’s or Carly’s?