The cuties Sophia Grace and Rosie have captured the hearts of celebs like Taylor Swift, Nicki Minaj and, of course, Ellen DeGeneres. Now they’ve got Justin Bieber wrapped around their adorable, little fingers!

The Biebs showed up to Tea Time with Sophia Grace and Rosie on The Ellen Show where they chatted about their favorite hobbies, what they’re afraid of and they’re favorite kinds of cake! But a line was drawn between them when the discussion of cookies was brought up.