View All Categories

Categories: Movie Reviews, MoviesTags: Brendan Fraser, Family, fantasy, journey to the center of the earth, Movie Reviews, science fiction

Jules Verne Growing Weary of Turning Over in his Grave - 'Journey to the Center of the Earth' Review...

journey-to-the-center-of-the-earth-3d-20080205064756707_640w.jpgErik Brevig, an experienced visual effects artist, makes his feature film directing debut with this update of Jules Verne's classic sci-fi novel about a group of people making an effort to reach the center of the earth to further mankind's scientific knowledge. Screenwriter Michael Weiss boasts an impressive list of crappy movies, including direct-to-video features like Octopus , Crocodile, U.S. Seals II (a sequel to a rip-off...), Octopus 2: River of Fear and, get this, I'll Always Know What You Did Last Summer. Good thing I researched all this after I saw the movie, otherwise I probably would have skipped it.

This is, however, the best version of the novel that has ever been made for the screen. I've seen most of the other film adaptations of the story, so I had low expectations but high hopes, since so much had been left undone as far as putting Verne's actual story on the screen.

While the previous films took wild liberties with the source, this one takes a completely different approach, it literally presents itself as though Jules Verne wrote the novel based on a true expedition. Professor Trevor Anderson (Brendan Fraser), carries a copy of the novel through the movie with him as sort of a map to guide him, his nephew Sean, and their hottie Icelandic mountain guide Hannah through the dangers that they encounter on their journey through the earth's crust.

40877445.jpg

In an effort to prove the potential truth of his long-missing brother's research and theories (and to get along with his smart-ass nephew), Anderson sets off on this quest to penetrate the earth's crust through a volcano in Iceland. What follows is a remarkably faithful presentation of Verne's story, which doesn't really matter because most people will be more interested in the 3D anyway.

And the 3D is impressive, by the way. We have come a long way since those red and blue sunglasses that just made everything look red and blue, the 3D here is so realistic that the obligatory jump-through-the-screen moments may cause even the most judicious of us to raise our eyebrows.

[caption id="" align="alignleft" width="313" caption="Professor Anderson wishing that Jules Verne had written a shorter book."]40764567.jpg[/caption]

Sadly, that realism is the new novelty, so the movie can't help halting in its tracks every ten minutes or so for a nice 3D wow-moment. I hate that.

It should be noted that this is a family film, so don't expect high adventure or danger the likes of which you should expect to find on a journey anywhere where no one has ever been before. As a guide, I have developed a theory that, in a movie like this, the character who doesn't know anything (Sean, the nephew), is about the age of the target audience, because he is the one that needs to have everything explained to him, for the audience's benefit. Sean is 13.

[caption id="" align="alignright" width="246" caption="See? Your standard eighth grade Earth Science book knows what it looks like in there!"]llnl_earth.jpg[/caption]

There is, however, an immediate and crippling discrepancy with the story. Before anything happens resembling any journey anywhere, we get a Toyota Prius commercial, a PSP commercial, plugs for Mountain Dew, Tivo, Family Guy, and Iceland Airlines, and the strange revelations that a PSP can "Google at 30,000 feet" and a punk teenager can receive calls on his cell phone while trapped miles below the earth's surface. That's news to me!

The problem is that the story of a journey, as Anderson describes it, through the earth's crust and into the mantle, requires a fundamental lack of modern scientific knowledge. So it follows that in a society that has commercial airlines, hybrid vehicles, portable video game devices that can search the internet at cruising altitude, cell phones that work anywhere on or in the planet, and modern computers, should also understand that a journey to the "center of the earth" is, as they say, an exercise in futility.

[caption id="" align="alignleft" width="270" caption="Professor Anderson and his nephew Sean, in a screen moment where they encounter a creature that betrays a stupendous lack of imagination on the part of the digital effects team. "]wek_journey071008d_29898c.jpg[/caption]

Nonetheless, this could be a great way to spend some time with the kids this weekend and, although there is one emotional moment and one romantic moment in the movie and both fall completely flat, it's not the worst date movie I've ever seen. There are some clever and amusing scenes ("We're STILL falling!") but also plenty of cheeseball dialogue and half-assed performances (Fraser's quivering lip is just too much...), but despite the roller coaster ride lifted right out of Indiana Jones and the bizarre idea of the magnetic rocks, the movie surpasses expectations. At least if you know what came before it...

.

The Bean Meter

[caption id="attachment_24501" align="aligncenter" width="184" caption="2.5 Beans out of 5."]2.5 Beans out of 5.[/caption]


Click to 'Heart This' Article
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on MySpaceShare on StumbleUponShare on DiggShare on DeliciousShare on RedditShare through E-Mail

    Comment viewing options

    Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
  • matthew  said:
    3 years ago (August 2, 2008 - 1:32pm) 0 Votes

    Yes if I had a penny (or nickel) for every time they re-made something that did or did not need re-making.

  • New DVDs This Week | Hollywire.com  said:
    3 years ago (December 17, 2008 - 1:47am) 0 Votes

    [...] Of course, none of this comes through in the movie, but it’s interesting nonetheless. The movie’s packed with special effects, too little Jet Li, and too much of Brendan Fraser’s trademark bad acting. But at least it was better than Journey to the Center of the Earth… [...]

  • Early 80’s Slasher Returns To Bore Us In 3D - ‘My Bloody Val  said:
    3 years ago (January 26, 2009 - 9:36pm) 0 Votes

    [...] which is good because until recently 3D was mostly reserved for weak family movies like the recent Journey to the Center of the Earth. I was glad to see 3D in a horror film, particularly one that wasn’t afraid to use the effect [...]

  • Early 80's Slasher Returns To Bore Us In 3D - 'My Bloody Val  said:
    3 years ago (January 30, 2009 - 5:13pm) 0 Votes

    [...] which is good because until recently 3D was mostly reserved for weak family movies like the recent Journey to the Center of the Earth. I was glad to see 3D in a horror film, particularly one that wasn’t afraid to use the effect [...]

  • Nicholas Cage Sees the Future Again - 'Knowing' Review... |   said:
    2 years ago (March 24, 2009 - 3:25am) 0 Votes

    [...] in terms of sheer emotional flatness, rivals the two similar belly-flops in  the hilariously bad Journey to the Center of the Earth starring Brendan Fraser, who is, ah, not exactly one of our most emotionally talented [...]

  • Hollywire's film writer sets world record! | Hollywire.com  said:
    2 years ago (April 21, 2009 - 5:54pm) 0 Votes

    [...] in there…), Coneheads, Monster Mash, Innerspace, Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, Journey to the Center of the Earth, TRON, Scooby Doo, The Clone Wars, 2001: A Space Odyssey and hence WALL-E, The Twilight Zone, I, [...]

  • Vampireland! ‘Cirque du Freak: The Vampire’s Assistant’ Revi  said:
    2 years ago (November 8, 2009 - 7:24pm) 0 Votes

    [...] talent needed to make a film series like this last. Massoglia, who I have decided to forgive for Journey to the Center of the Earth, even reminds me a lot of Jared Rushton as Tom Hanks‘ friend Billy in [...]

  • Ice Age: Dawn of the Dinosaurs Review | Hollywire.com  said:
    1 year ago (February 27, 2010 - 4:52am) 0 Votes

    [...] There are plenty of reasons to slam the third Ice Age movie as a money grab made for no other reason than because a T-rex looked good on the movie poster, but there are many more reasons to sit back and take in the incredible animated creations that are put forth in it and allow yourself to accept it as a high entertaining, if not exactly educational, piece of family fun. The adventures that our heroes encounter in this extraordinary underground world are wonderfully imagined and beautifully animated, easily surpassing the mediocre realization of Jules Verne’s brilliant classic novel into the bonehead 2008 film Journey to the Center of the Earth. [...]

  • ‘Love Happens’ Review… | Hollywire.com  said:
    1 year ago (February 27, 2010 - 5:04am) 0 Votes

    [...] product placement. You want flagrant, billboard-over-the-head product placement, go back and watch Journey to the Center of the Earth again. At least it meant something here. And by the way, why does love never seem to happen to [...]

  • Instructional Video in 3D! - ‘How to Train Your Dragon’ Revi  said:
    1 year ago (March 31, 2010 - 8:15am) 0 Votes

    [...] presented in incredibly detailed 3D and yet never feels the need to stop in its tracks to have some goofball 3d moment where a sword or something comes poking out into the audience and we’re supposed to go ooh and [...]

  • Post new comment

    10 Comments Show Newest FirstShow More
    Cancel

Inside Fivel Stewart's World!
Need celeb news now? We've got you covered. Stay connected... JOIN HOLLYWIRE your insider Hollywood connection Connect with Facebook