For those of you who don’t know, for two years I have been teaching at the Luoyang University of Science and Technology in the central-eastern province of Henan. The recent outrage among Chinese Americans about Miley Cyrus’ “slant-eyed” picture scandal went wholly unnoticed here on the mainland, so I was inspired to bring Jackie Chan’s recent comments about freedom for Chinese people to the attention of my Chinese college students and report about it here on Hollywire.
At a recent business conference in Hainan, the island province in the south of China west of Hong Kong, Chan made this comment -
“I’m not sure if it’s good to have freedom or not. If you’re too free, you’re like the way Hong Kong is now. It’s very chaotic. Taiwan is also chaotic. I’m gradually beginning to feel that the we Chinese need to be controlled. If we’re not being controlled, we’ll just do what we want.”
The Chinese are a fiercely proud culture and take deep offense to foreigners who criticize their country or government. Something like Miley Cyrus’ picture scandal doesn’t even show up on the radar over here, but something like Jack Cafferty’s thoughtless remarks on CNN last year caused a major, major uproar throughout the mainland.
This time, however, the offensive remarks are coming from none other than Jackie Chan, arguably the most famous Chinese superstar in the world. Hong Kong legislator Leung Kwok-hung called Chan’s remarks “insulting” to the Chinese people and insisted that “the Chinese aren’t pets.”
Hong Kong and Taiwanese news outlets, as well as foreign sources, have reported on Chan’s comments, but the situation has been largely ignored by the press in mainland China. Now for the first time, Hollywire’s foreign correspondent in China (that’s me) will bring you the common perspective of a few of the citizens of the Chinese mainland (read more reactions at end of this article).
“I think what Jackie Chan said is right. We Chinese have been controlled for a long time. We don’t know what is right. We need our government to lead us.”
-Fan Di, 19
Luoyang, China
“I think everyone needs freedom. Everyone can do whatever they want. If we want to do something, no one can control us. China is the same as any other country.”
-Wang Jing, 21,
Luoyang, China
“I agree with Jackie Chan’s opinion. The population of China is too large. If everyone has freedom, they’ll do whatever they want and our lives will be a mess. Civilization or society will be in a degraded state.”
-Li Long Fei, 21
Sanmenxia, China

The Luoyang Institute of Science and Technology.
As of today, Chan is not welcome in Taiwan, and the Democratic Progressives Party have called for him to be cut as the spokesman for the Deaflympics team, and blogcritics.org has made the rather ridiculous statement that “Chan is a fascist.” You can agree with Chan or not, or side with the current avalanche of criticism, but we could all do well to stop for a second and have a look at what real, everyday Chinese people think about Jackie Chan and freedom for their country.
The following are some more written thoughts from some of my Chinese college students:
“I think I agree with him. I think many Chinese people only care about themselves, and they don’t want to carry out some of the basic duties of citizenship. So, I think Chinese need to be controlled.”
-Su Li Jun, 20
Luoyang, China
“I think his words are too extreme. Freedom and control must exist together. Without some kind of control, pure freedom is only theoretical. But without freedom, control can only make everything worse.”
-Wang Pan Pan, 22
Han Gu Guan, China
“I think what he said is right, because sometimes people need to be controlled. If we can do what we want, society will not develop.”
-Wang Yi, 19
Luoyang, China
“I think Jackie Chan’s words are right, it’s in accordance with the Chinese situation. If everyone has freedom and there is no control, the society will become chaos. It’s a bad thing for our country.”
-Tian Yi Ping, 20
Luoyang, China
“I have no idea why Jackie Chan would say these words, but I think his view is too extreme.”
-Li Long, 21
Kai Feng, China
“I agree with that. I think freedom is relative. There are many people in China. If everyone does what they want to do, maybe the society will become disorderly.”
-Liu Shu, 20
Luoyang, China
“I agree with Jackie’s view. We should be controlled. Because our citizens have not reached a high level of competence.”
-Zhang Jia Bao, 20
Luoyang, China
“I think freedom is good for Chinese, but control is necessary for some people. If everyone is free maybe some people will only care to profit for themselves.”
-Ma Dan Wei, 20
Luoyang, China
“I think he is right. As we all know, most Chinese are farmers. They just know how to work in a farm situation. If all people have freedom, there will be many troubles. So I think he is right.”
-Mao Shuai, 21
Xin Xiang, China
“I think the Chinese need freedom because the Chinese people are honest and great, so the world should give us our freedom.”
-Zhang Zhao, 21
Luoyang China
“I think the Chinese need to have freedom. Mostly all Chinese people are kind-hearted, so I think Jackie Chan’s idea is very extreme.”
-Qin Tian Tian, 21
Luoyang, China
“I think the Chinese need freedom. If we have freedom, we will get what we want and we will live in a happy life.”
-Gao Pan, 21
Jiao Zuo, China
“I agree with Jackie Chan. China has too many people so not everyone can do what they want to do.”
-Zhang Xu, 20
Luoyang, China
“I think the Chinese need freedom. In the old times, all the people were controlled. They were too eager to have freedom and it caused wars. Then the peace was broken.”
-Guo Yan, 20
Nan Yang, China
“I think his opinion is right, because is people have too little restraint, society will become confusion. We will not have a normal life.”
-Zhang Xue Wen, 21
Xin Yang, China
“I think the Chinese need freedom but we also need rules to control us. China has a huge population. If we are not controlled, our country will develop slowly.”
-Yao Dong, 21
Ji Yuan, China
“I think that what Jackie Chan said is right. Because China has so many people that is we all have freedom it will lead to a society of confusion.”
-Zuo Ya Ting, 19
Xin Xiang, China
“I think the media has mistaken what Jackie Chan means. He means that Hong Kong and Taiwan are too free, so that they can’t control their actions. Because Hong Kong and Taiwan are more open than the mainland, the people think they study everything from abroad, but they’re wrong.”
-Hu Yuan, 22
Sanmenxia, China
“I think he’s right. If there are no rules, people will become more selfish. Because of people’s greed, more and more crimes will appear.”
-Jin Qian, 20
Luoyang, China
“I think it’s good for the Chinese to have freedom. China has been controlled for a long time, so the Chinese don’t have comfortable freedom now. It only needs time, Chinese can study to use the freedom.”
-Ji Yan Wu, 21
Luoyang, China
“I think Jackie Chan’s opinion is right. In China, all Chinese people are controlled. Sometimes I feel that we can’t say something about our own ideas or do something that we want. Chinese people should have freedom.”
-Jin Bo, 21
Xin Yang, China
“I think his remark is very good. That’s a good idea, I agree with him, because this is Chinese tradition.”
-Li Xiao Kai, 21
Luoyang, China
“I think Jackie Chan’s view is right. I support his remark, because China has a big population and if the Chinese are not under control it will cause big troubles.”
-Qiao Zong Lei, 22
Xin Zheng, China
“I agree with Jackie Chan, because China’s population is too big and if people are not under control the country will become a mess.”
-Du Yu, 21
Nan Yang, China
“I think Jackie Chan’s remark is right. We Chinese really need to be controlled. This way we can avoid many troubles.”
-Zheng Xuan, 21
Luoyang, China
“I agree with Jackie Chan. Chinese people need to be controlled. Not all Chinese people need freedom.”
-Hu Xin Yu, 22
Luoyang, China
“I don’t agree with Jackie Chan’s words. Because I think freedom is very important. If we don’t have freedom, we are not living a full life.”
-Wang Jin, 21
Luoyang, China
“I think Jackie Chan is right because we must have order.”
-Li Shao Kai, 21
Luoyang, China
“I think Jackie Chan’s freedom remarks are not exactly right. He doesn’t understand our Chinese abilities. Everyone needs freedom, including us. We don’t have it yet, but how do you know that we can’t make good use of it?”
-Wang Yang, 19
Sanmenxia, China